Hartleys Pizza
If you're in the mood for some mouthwatering pizza in Cumberland, MD, Hartleys Pizza is the place to be. Located at 432 Williams St, this cozy restaurant has earned a reputation for serving up delicious, handcrafted pizzas that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you're a fan of classic cheese or prefer something with a little more kick, Hartleys has a variety of options that are sure to satisfy.
One of the things that sets Hartleys Pizza apart is their commitment to quality. Each pizza is made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are always generous – no skimping here! Plus, their menu doesn't stop at just pizza. From savory pasta dishes to mouthwatering appetizers, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
The atmosphere at Hartleys Pizza is casual and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed dinner with friends or family. The friendly staff always makes sure you feel right at home, offering excellent service and making recommendations if you're unsure what to order. And if you’re in a hurry or prefer to dine in the comfort of your own home, Hartleys offers takeout and delivery options for your convenience.
If you’re planning to stop by, don’t forget to try some of their signature pizzas. Their specialty pies, like the BBQ Chicken or the Veggie Supreme, are a crowd favorite and showcase the creative flair that Hartleys brings to every dish. For dessert, you can’t go wrong with a slice of their decadent cheesecake – the perfect end to your meal.
So, if you're craving some of the best pizza in town, Hartleys Pizza in Cumberland is your go-to destination. With a menu full of fresh ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s easy to see why this local gem continues to be a favorite among pizza lovers.
Reviews
Stumbled upon this place today. It's a very basic walk in pizza place. Aesthetically it is nothing special but the food was really good. We got a buffalo chicken pizza as well as a steak and cheese. The pizza was delicious, a lot of cheese, food amount of chicken, good size container of bleu cheese, a little more buffalo would have been nice tho. My dad really enjoyed steak and cheese. I'd definitely go back and try another pizza and the wings!
Been eating here since I was young great pizza. I would highly recommend getting the champ pizza if you have a large family that is hungry.
Always have to come back here when I come in town. Their pizza is okay but their cheese sticks and wedgies are fantastic and always are included in our order. I personally like the wings, very wet and not too crunchy as is my wing palette. Their staff is a little abrasive, but not too bad for a dude who lived in philly and DC, hence the -1 Star(I know other reviewers didn't appreciate the level of customer interface). Otherwise, brilliant place. Also only accepts cash! And I posted the menu.
Has been a staple in my hometown for many decades before and will be for decades to come. I have been ordering from this place long before you people were in diapers and so much so that I know their number by heart: 3017593095. There. There really is no wrong answer here: EXCEPT you cannot buy a circular pizza. If you get a pizza get a CHAMP. Square cuts, 16, and so incredibly good. There's nothing special about the pizza- it's more built to go rather than for show but has been a must-have forever. In terms of their wings - they are very good usually just going with mild or medium, and the wings always come with carrots and celery as well as one of my top 3 bleu cheeses of all time anywhere in the Western Hemisphere. The most underrated and best-kept secret they have on the menu is the cheese sticks and pepperoni sticks which are not the traditional logs and fries but rather a square flip type pizza with cheese in the middle that's "perforated" to show the cheese Inside. Incredible. My favorite pastime always was to get the 2 small wedgies for $7.99 with coupon with my dad when we would watch games - him going with the steak and I either the steak or the roast beef. I miss that more than anything really. As for the chicken and subs- I only recall getting them once and it was your traditional run of the mill food. Highly recommended
Was browsing Yelp & noticed Hartley's is only averaging 3 stars, had to drop everything to correct this miscarriage of justice, set you nerds straight. This place is as Cumberland as teen pregnancy, church steeples, and that weirdo who sells his homemade CDs down by the post office -- so if you ain't from here, you probably won't get it. Whatever, go make some avocado toast & sniff your own farts, bro. The actual food you ask? Sometimes sublime, sometimes god-awful. But I mean it's Hartley's, and anytime you're dining on Hartley's life can't be all that bad, eh. Also, they still take a check! Hungry for a Champ Pizza but not enough ducats in the ole bank account? Some other schmancy jawn isn't trying to care. But call up Hartley's and you got yourself a dinner on the float, son. Now comes the exciting game of "Will they cash the check before I get paid?" That's value-added! Anyway, I like Hartley's. They also have a voicemail that says they're open from Wednesday through Monday. Who chooses to convey the fact that they're closed on Tuesdays in that manner? GD Hartley's, that's who!